9 photos on this listing. See all on Google Maps.
About Magic Nail
Magic Nail is a nail salon at 4421 Mahoning Ave B in Youngstown, Ohio, also listed as a beauty salon. It holds a Google rating of 3.6 from 170 reviews. Recent reviewers mostly praise individual technicians by name, including Amber, Jeremy, Henry and Tiffany, while one older review from 4 years ago describes a poor experience. It is open seven days and priced at the $$$ level.
What Magic Nail offers
Magic Nail is listed as a nail salon, with beauty salon as a secondary category. Reviewers name manicures and pedicures, acrylic sets and a sharp stiletto shape, and one reviewer says the salon matched a design they had seen and liked.
The reviews come from repeat customers, one of whom lets only one technician do their mani and pedi, and from first-time visitors who describe a courteous welcome.
What customers say about Magic Nail
Four of the five review excerpts give 5 stars and one gives 1 star, while the overall Google rating stands at 3.6 from 170 reviews. Reviewers mention technicians by name. One review from 2 months ago says Amber listened to requests and handled the visit very well. Another, from 3 months ago, says Tiffany does a fabulous job and is the only person that reviewer lets do a mani and pedi.
A review from a year ago praises Jeremy for his work and says Henry applied acrylics in the stiletto shape the customer wanted. It describes the staff as welcoming and kind, the atmosphere as good and the prices as amazing. A first-time visitor from a year ago says the staff took their time, did a thorough job and never made them feel rushed.
The critical review dates from 4 years ago. The reviewer paid $100 in total plus a pedicure, reports a swollen finger days after the appointment and says a nail had to be removed from a fresh set. They also describe the staff as unprofessional and rude, and say the manager disputed their account.
Hours, prices and payment at Magic Nail
Magic Nail is open seven days a week. Monday through Friday hours are 10 AM to 7 PM, Saturday is 10 AM to 6 PM, and Sunday is 11 AM to 5 PM.
The listing puts prices at $$$, described as expensive. Reviewers who comment on value are positive: one calls the prices amazing, and another was pleasantly surprised at how reasonable the cost was given the time spent on their nails. The critical review cites $100 in total plus a pedicure. The salon accepts credit cards and contactless payment.
Location and access for Magic Nail in Youngstown
The listing shows a wheelchair accessible entrance, accessible parking and an accessible restroom. The salon is at 4421 Mahoning Ave B in Youngstown, Mahoning County, Ohio, United States.
Questions about Magic Nail
Is Magic Nail open on Sunday?
Yes. Magic Nail is open on Sunday from 11 AM to 5 PM. Weekday hours are 10 AM to 7 PM, and Saturday hours are 10 AM to 6 PM.
Does Magic Nail take cards?
Yes. The listing says Magic Nail accepts credit cards and contactless payment. Its price level is $$$, which is described as expensive.
How is Magic Nail rated?
Magic Nail has a Google rating of 3.6 from 170 reviews. Recent reviews praise Amber, Jeremy, Henry and Tiffany by name, while one review from 4 years ago is critical.
Is Magic Nail wheelchair accessible?
The listing shows a wheelchair accessible entrance, accessible parking and an accessible restroom at Magic Nail, 4421 Mahoning Ave B in Youngstown.
Where is Magic Nail in Youngstown?
Magic Nail is at 4421 Mahoning Ave B in Youngstown, Mahoning County, Ohio, United States.
Written by the SpaSpot editorial team from this business's public Google listing and 170 customer reviews, then checked against the listing data on October 17, 2026. It describes what customers report and is not medical advice. How we research and write listings · Report a correction.
Photo tour (8 photos, 21 seconds)
Play the photo tourA short slideshow of this business's public Google Business Profile photos.
- Delphine Hudson2 months ago
Amber was the epitome of excellence! She listened to my requests and handled my needs very well!
- Ely Parisa year ago
Absolutely blown away. Took a chance on a local salon for a neat design I liked and they blew it out of the water. Jeremy is absolutely amazing at what he does, Henry laid my acrylic and gave me the ideal sharp stiletto. Staff is very welcoming and kind, good atmosphere and amazing prices. I’ll definitely be coming to Jeremy from now on 🖤
- Lynn Knish3 months ago
As always Tiffany does a FABULOUS job, I won't let anyone do my mani/pedi but her.
- Bre'Asia Casey4 years ago
Got my nails done Friday April 15th, 5 days after i was dealing with pain for the whole period and today i woke up to a swollen finger had to come back and get a nail removed from a fresh set, i paid $100 total plus a pedicure just to have a infected nail never again will i come back to this place very unprofessional they don’t acknowledge you very rude and the manager was talking about i was lying and said i bumped my nail into something when i didn’t meanwhile while i was there another lady mouthed that she was never coming back because she got regular polish instead of gel polish now i might have to take a trip to the emergency room because of this place ! avoid this place at all cost not worth your health! been getting acrylic nails for years and never ever have this happened before ever
- Susan Morleya year ago
I went for the first time yesterday. They were very courteous and took their time doing a very thorough job on my nails. I did not feel rushed at all and considering the time they spent on my nails i was pleasantly surprised at how reasonable it was. I will definitely be back and highly recommend them.
Showing the 5 reviews Google marks as most relevant, of 170. Read all on Google.
Location
4421 Mahoning Ave B, Youngstown, OH 44515, USAGet directions
Nail salon in Youngstown, OH
Magic Nail serves Youngstown in Mahoning County. Its 3.6 rating comes from 170 customer reviews on Google. Compare it with every spa and salon in Youngstown, see the top 10 in Youngstown, or browse nail salons across Ohio.











